Your guide to the region's top events, mixed with some commentary about life, media, gossip and politics in Washington, DC.
|
Why Andy Beyer Is Wrong—Sadly, Badly Wrong—About His Kentucky Derby Picks
By
Kim Eisler
See Kim Eisler's Derby picks here.
For many years Washington Post horse racing writer Andrew Beyer was my hero. For a time, after the publication of his influential handicapping book Picking Winners, I became a virtual stalker, leaving messages on his answering machine and trying to sidle up next to him during the Daily Double at the old Sports Palace at Laurel Race Course.
Over the years, our relationship has cooled, largely because now we actually know each other.
Be that as it may, Andy never has been able to really get a handle on the Kentucky Derby. For many years, he admitted to his Derby cluelessness. Meanwhile, my own list of Derby successes has been pretty impressive. I picked the Derby winners in 2006 and 2007, Barbaro and Street Sense. I have nailed such unlikely winners as Winning Colors in 1998, Sunday Silence in 1989, Strike the Gold in 1991, Silver Charm in 1997, and Fusaichi Pegasus in 2000 (See Kim's current Derby picks here). I doubt whether Beyer had any of them.
For those who don’t closely follow racing, Andy is the guru, the Einstein who created the “Beyer Speed Figures.” From the mid 1970s until last year, the Beyer Speed Figures were the greatest advance in the history of gambling. For many years one had to buy his book and figure out how to compute them. I spents hundreds of hours of my life doing that. Then the Daily Racing Form decided to buy the Beyer Speed Figures and print them next to the entries and past performances for every horse at every track in America.
It was nice not to have to spend seven to eight hours every night doing the math. On the other hand, now anybody could pay $5 for the paper and get the numbers. Horses with high Beyer numbers, now widely circulated, would immediately be bet down at the windows. To try to scrounge out a profit, the trick became trying to use the numbers, trying to figure which horses were likely to replicate numbers and which were likely to “bounce” off of them and run a poorer race than the last number.
Beyer numbers were predicated on the fact that not every racing surface in America was the same. Dirt tracks varied not only from place to place, but from day to day. How fast a horse could run on a particular track could be affected by rain and wind. Andy had figured out how to compare and adjust all racing surfaces and change a horse’s final time into one handy “Beyer” number.
And then two years ago, something bad happened to Beyer Speed Figures. To try to make racing surfaces safer for the horses, state racing commissions began mandating the installation of “synthetic” racing surfaces to replace the old dirt tracks. The first two places to put it in were Turfway Park and Keeneland Racetrack in Kentucky. Now all the major tracks in Southern California, Santa Anita, Hollywood Park, and Del Mar also have it.
This was great for the horses, but not so good for the industry that had become Beyer Speed Figures. Synthetic tracks show very little variance from day to day. Overnight, the tracks had rendered Beyer obsolete. It was as if one day a scientist had disproven E=MC2, and it went from a principle of physics to a dusty footnote.
Beyer has not taken this well. Despite his personal and financial interst in the topic, the Washington Post has run columns from him critical of the surface switch, even though the evidence that it saves the lives of horses seems indisputable.
Beyer has become obsessed with the switch to synthetic race tracks, but never has that become more clear than in his Derby picks this year. In past years, Beyer would still use the basic principles of handicapping, looking at pedigree, past performances, recent form, trainer and jockey analysis. His own Beyer speed figures would be considered as well.
But this year his picks came down to one simple calculation. Beyer has thrown out any horse that ran well on a synthetic track and picked any horse that didn’t. In effect he has bet on himself. He hates synthetic racetracks and won’t pick any horse that does. His top Derby selection this year is Pyro. His rationale for picking Pyro was that this colt ran his worst race in the Blue Grass Stakes at Keeneland. Beyer dismissed with contempt Monba, the horse that won the race and finished 11 lengths ahead of Pyro. Beyer’s second choices in the Derby is Z Fortune. Beyer loves Z Fortune, a homely New York-bred horse with a modest racing record for one simple reason—his hooves have never touched the hated synthetic tracks.
Horses that have won traditional stepping stone races to the Derby at all dirt Churchill Downs, like Santa Anita Derby winner Colonel John and Blue Grass Stakes winner Monba, Beyer says to put an X through.
For him, it’s as simple as that. Beyer has become Ahab, obsessed by the great white synthetic race track that he can’t understand and which is destroying his life’s work.
Even in the best of times, Beyer was never able to understand the dynamics of the Kentucky Derby. Now he has picked Pyro to win in a sense to redeem his own life’s work.
The fact is that Colonel John, although all his races have been in Southern California, loves the dirt track. His morning workouts have been nothing short of amazing. It is a truism of racing that a great horse can run on anything. Colonel John, whose sire won not one but two Breeders Cup Classic races, will show that to be the case on Saturday.
And Beyer didn’t mention a horse in the race named Court Vision, #4. Court Vision won two stakes as a two year old, and one of them was right here at Churchill Downs and the other at Aqueduct. But he also won a race on the synthetic track at Keeneland, proving that adage about a good horse and any surface.
Watch for Court Vision to be coming after Colonel John in the stretch and box your exacta, 4-10 and 10-4, for a big payoff on Derby Day.
More>> Capital Comment Blog | News & Politics | Society Photos
|
Category Tags: Reads, Sports
Comments
to buy <a href=http://uobconnect.org/blog.php?user=cornsweepgesch&blogentry_id=223887>lvreplica-purses.com-0121</a> for more detail <a href=http://www.shachahworldministries.com/node/14451>lvreplica-purses.com-0121</a> and check coupon code available
Posted by: RenEmell, Jan 22, 2012 10:39:54 AM
7 At the end of the air filled with the desire to shop, windows everywhere Sale, the people involved in purchasing again and again the tide. As long as you look accurate, it is cheaper to buy a variety of favorite long can the good goods. can be concentrated in such raids without reckoning wanton procurement, but also easy to lose, so their reduced to "junk woman".
shopping, celebrities have always charge the former, experience is particularly rich . The stars of the shopping in Hong Kong after discount on large numbers of summer vacation in Hong Kong were more strongly into China. But the star, after all, not a fashion designer, was at a higher level, the reason gold, this issue also invite more place the most active designers and fashion people, personally surgeon, to help you sort out the change of the fashion pulse of new and old, peeling silkworm spinning, out of season rush to buy discount focus and dedication from their losses and gains experience.
Cecilia
raids Location: Times Square, Causeway Bay shopping
focus: the rebate, is cost-effective to buy cosmetics. In addition, Times Square, selling all kinds of girls clothing all year round, it is suitable for Cecilia’s style.
link Beijing: China Friendship Department Store < br> bag bargains key: even if a discount, the top big things, or very expensive. Therefore, learning to Cecilia, a down to meet their own tastes, purchasing power of local girls shopping for their installed it.
Vision Xuan
1. Fast shipping ,Best quaity products,
2. Payment Method : Accept Paypal,Western Union ,Money Gram,
3. and give free shipping, Accept the smallest order,
4. EMS,DHL,TNT,FEDEX etc.
Welcome into our WEB: http://www.cheapsneakercn.com
or http://www.newsneakerswholesale.com
raids Location: Pacific Place shopping
focus: Jessica, said: "buying things, the mood is most important, a discount is still followed. discount when the mind to keep the wrong reason will not buy a shirt. "seasonal, the Pacific Place and other brands such as D & G will hit 5 discount, shoppers are crazy. Jessica shopping frenzy does not belong to the girl, she likes to enjoy a leisurely way to try on clothes in the environment.
Link Beijing: Palace Hotel
bag bargains focus: a world-class brand of seasonal goods, but also enjoy five-star shopping environment. discount store dressing room to be some period of long lines, very annoying.
Carina Lau
mop Location: Central, The Landmark
shopping points: famous discount, the Carina is often the first time in the Landmark in Central to buy some clothes. waiting there almost every day, paparazzi photographed celebrities visiting the shop shapes and sizes. If there were paparazzi be exposed Shu Qi in the Landmark bought the former boyfriend Dawn LV purse.
link Beijing: International Trade
bag bargains focus: mature women have the economic strength of the F1 layer of the LV,cheap jordan shoes, Max & Mara and other big discount, absolutely immense interest.
Shirley
1. Fast shipping ,Best quaity products,
2. Payment Method : Accept Paypal,Western Union ,Money Gram,
3. and give free shipping, Accept the smallest order,
4. EMS,DHL,TNT,FEDEX etc.
Welcome into our WEB: http://www.cheapsneakercn.com
or http://www.newsneakerswholesale.com
raids Location: City Plaza shopping
points: Shirley admitted that discount when buying more for the family, prefer the design of flu in some famous small jewelry, see the chic, will be more to buy some souvenirs. Shirley that time to the mid-range priced discount shopping, more affordable, cost-effective.
link Beijing: Oriental Plaza
bag bargains focus :louis vuitton handbags There are many new jewelry store in particular is worth watching.nike shoes
Tsang
raids Location: Causeway Bay shopping Crawford
key: Do not look to see Eric Tsang, in fact, but his authentic "human fashion . "discount in August each year seven seasons, Crawford boutique often as low as 6 fold, Eric Tsang usually discounted selection of men’s time,replica IWC, including attending events to wear suits, usually wear casual clothes when shopping and so on.
Link Beijing: Lufthansa
bag bargains focus: Lufthansa Men do not fancy, but definitely has the quality of content, clothing brands such as BOSS, Xenia class brand, should be the successful man not to be missed Taobao focus.
Anthony Wong
raids Location: Causeway Bay SOGO SOGO shopping
focus: shopping is clearly not just a small girl’s patent, even if it rough as Anthony Wong’s "character man" is also keen to Shopping, I once SOGO SOGO Department Store in Causeway Bay and saw Anthony Wong, accompanied by the Assistant buy clothes. He admitted that from time to time the discount SOGO activities is to attract one of the reasons he went. Anthony Wong preference with punk-style clothing, hand-painted T-shirts and with nail jeans will let Anthony Wong put it down.
link Beijing: SOGO, Parkson
bag bargains key: do not discount timing activities,mbt shoes give you a lot of value for money windfall.
Ekin Cheng
mop Location: Sai Yee Street, (Shoes Street)
shopping focus: not so in love with actress and cosmetics to buy pretty dresses everywhere, like the movement of Ekin Cheng usually buy more emphasis on sports and leisure shoes, so Sneaker Street in Mong Kok he must be free to visit the place. Shoes Street stores selling NIKE, ADIDAS and so on of the newest sports and leisure shoes are usually sold at prices of seven Bazhe it off for the birth does not know how frugal is Ekin Cheng It is a very economical choice, so he does not shoot as long as it will go to buy a few pairs of sneakers Street favorite shoes home.
link Beijing: SOGO Oriental Plaza Sports 100
bag bargains Focus: Sports class clothing. Movement like you, discount,mbt shoes be sure to buy some more.
She Poetry Man
raids Location: Harbour City, Tsim Sha Tsui shopping
points: Poetry Man She always busy filming, not so ordinary girl visit this store a lot of time, so she likes to Harbour City, you can also see the works of famous fashion designers and international famous brand stores, discount focus when, against a lot of things to be able to Amoy.
Link Beijing: World all Stores
bag bargains focus: people who do not have much time, the best brands on all of this high place,replica Rolex, one will be able to scrape together almost.
1. Fast shipping ,Best quaity products,
2. Payment Method : Accept Paypal,Western Union ,Money Gram,
3. and give free shipping, Accept the smallest order,
4. EMS,DHL,TNT,FEDEX etc.
Welcome into our WEB: http://www.cheapsneakercn.com
or http://www.newsneakerswholesale.com
Posted by: sneakercn, Jun 29, 2011 06:02:00 AM
I agree partially with you, where I believe you are a 100% right is that not all the high Byr’s lead you to pick up the right winner horse on the race, my disappointment doing this for years made me to created my own speed chart figures based exclusively on my notes that I have been taken trough the years on what I have observed and learned watching the races in how the field of horses ran that day and reviewing the PP and pedigree as well and some other factors too. Something to say is that the favorite who has the highest Byr figure doesn’t make him a winner, there are some horses in the race that because its pedigree and style of running are going to affect and to influence the outcome of the race tremendoudly, and not t to say much just yesterday August1st, 2010, I picked the winner horse, Beachrock that won the 6th race at Del Mar race track, payoffs; $20.40 $9.00 and $6.80 and nobody is going to contradict me the way that I picked the winner by relating to my own notes and charts that I have created myself to interpret speed, class, distance, pedigree and even more. In the ancient times the Egyptians were great in astrology just by observing the stars, taking notes and studying them and helping themselves doing the math as well, so in picking winners in horse raicing there is nothing different and that is what I exactly do but it is necessary to learn first all the possible’ angles’ in horse racing, first and most important thing is to interpret correctly the PP reading it is not enough, and however is serious in horse racing may agree with me that it is necessary to create your own ‘charts –work tools’ to help yourself to interpret the figures on the DRF, meaning to create speed charts for your favorite races tracks and to create charts for every change of distance, from sprint race to route race and vice versa, when switch from Synthetic to turf or vice versa, first time facing Alw’s, OC 50k/n-1, 3yrs old, 1st time Clm etc; also to know about trainer’s profile is a must to know the way they workout their horses to win a race and also to have a good idea when the trainer has entered his horse in the right race to win it or he is going only to give his horse an stretch out, another important angle is to know about pedigree, which horses according to his sire strikes on his first outing in Alw, Clm, Mdn, Turf, sprint or route distances etc. So that is what I’m referring about creating your own charts, if you don’t don’t do ‘your homework’ it is better to stay out from horse racing you would be only burning money.
Posted by: carlos Delavega, Aug 02, 2010 08:12:59 PM
It has now been shown, as of 2009, that synthetic surfaces are really no better then dirt as far as far as injuries and death goes. Stick with A. Beyer, the man knows what he’s talking about
Posted by: linda, Sep 08, 2009 07:38:45 AM
Well he did pick Street Sense two years ago in the DRF, the Post and elsewhere, so your "I doubt Beyer had him" throws into doubt that you actually know anything about Beyer or what he has picked.
Posted by: Jerry, Apr 28, 2009 05:13:05 AM
Great article, your only a year behind.
Posted by: guninpocket, Apr 21, 2009 03:05:24 AM
I’ll see the author’s Winning Colors, Sunday Silence etc; etc; and raise her one Arcangues--Bertrando exacta that paid 900-1.
"Traditional" handicapping methods are essentially useless in the majority of races since they do not take into consideration information known only to the horse’s connections. How close is the horse to it’s ideal running weight? A difference of two or three stones (30-40 pounds) can result in a horse running up the track.
What is the true condition of the course--not the one designated on the tote board but the actual condition as determined by a trainer and jockey walking the course before a race. The track labelled fast may be deep and testing because of the drying effects of steady winds.
The day A.P. Andy won the 1992 Peter Pan there was a freakish windshear at midstretch. Entering the stretch A.P. Indy was assisted by a tail wind; at the eighth pole he was bucky a 20-knot headwind.
Similarly when he finished out of the frame in the Molson million it was discovered only after the race that he was suffering from an infected throat.
When Swale lost the ’84 Preakness only Woody Stephens and Lafitt Pincay knew it was because a rock-hard track has stung Swale’s tender feet.
(Arcangues, by the way, had a disc problem in his back which Andre Fabre and the Wildersteins (and I) knew about. Not one writer in the world press mentioned it in the analysis of the ’93 Classic.
The bottom line? There are no shortcuts to ferreting out the winner of a race. No magic numbers or principles.
Invariably, it’s a tedious business much like Scotland Yard knocking on doors to find clues about the identity of a thief.
Beyer is guilty of nothing more than giving American horseplayers what they want but which does not exist: a
simple tool to solve one of the most maddening riddles in sport: who will come home first.
Posted by: JCarpenter06@optonline.net, May 24, 2008 05:23:35 PM
A sportswriter in Chicago adduced formulas to use Beyer Speed Figures to trim KDerby and Preakness fields down to a handful of probables with great success. His name is Jim O’Donnell. I think his system - ODage, a play on Dosage - has hit something like 26 straight Triple Crowns races. Caveat: Some races, he is left with three or four possibles. It’s interesting
Posted by: Mike from Brook Park, Ohio, May 16, 2008 11:11:13 PM
Andy sat down next to me at Saratoga about 20 years ago and we had a discussion on the merits of Five Star Flight in the Travers. (He lost) But Andy is a nice guy, no megalomaniac. I also recall back in 1990 he was one of ten to share in a $1.34 million double triple so he is no dummy hadicapper. I would admit ,however ,that the Derby is not his best race.
Posted by: RexdePlumbum, May 06, 2008 09:43:39 AM
You made a couple of valid points even though both yours and his picks stunk. His throw outs were mainly in the bottom of the heap with Monba finishing 59 1/4 lengths behind and despite Coronel John’s great workout, he never fired at the end.
Posted by: George, May 05, 2008 10:34:18 AM
Invest in a spell checker.
Posted by: Don Otenlong, May 05, 2008 09:34:56 AM
sorry i got in the way of your bet. and guess what ? beyer is right! all these horses that are running on the "tires" are throw outs!
Posted by: bigbrown, May 04, 2008 07:14:57 AM
You were right about one thing: Andy’s ability to pick winners in the Derby has proven elusive over time. He was right to recommend ignoring those horses coming off of huge synthetic surrface performances, however, as they all ran up the track in this yr’s Derby. And your questioning his motives was disgraceful (the whole column was a thinly veiled ad hominem attack). What you seem to miss is horses that excel on synthetic surfaces very often don’t perform well on dirt tracks. Churchill is a dirt track. Ergo, Andy pitched the synthetic-loving horses. Got it? It doesn’t have anything to do with his Beyer Speed Figure franchise. If you’re wondering, I’ve never met Andy Beyer and I certainly have no monetary interest in his business. I’m just pointing out the obvious, i.e., you have no idea what you’re talking about when it comes to Andy’s thoughts on betting synthetic surface lovers in the Derby.
Posted by: Mike, May 04, 2008 06:25:52 AM
Dear Kim,
In reviewing your criticism of Andrew Beyer’s Derby picks for 2008, I feel you have made quite a mockery of yourself and demonstrated a significant lack of handicapping expertise. It is clear that Big Brown’s performance was a standout and for the first time in 30+ years, we may actually be witness to a Triple Crown celebration. You felt Big Brown had a poor chance of winning based on a number of lame excuses. I suppose the performance and results speak for themselves. I feel it was very unprofessional of the way you criticized Andrew Beyer. I could go on an on about the negative approach to your lambasting of Andrew Beyer and your poor Derby picks. Your article speaks true colours about your lack of ability and class. Yesterday, based on the betting strategies I learned from reading Andrew Beyers books and the fact that Big Brown had the highest Beyer speed figures in the race, I keyed all my exotics around Big Brown. I wagered $164 on the race and my key $1 tri-key bet was 20/1,5,6,9,10,16,18,19. I walked away winning 1/2 of the tri valued at $1,700 plus. It was a "king of the world" experience. (thanks Andy). Perhaps you could tone your criticism down in the future. Your last article made you look rather foolish.
David from Canada
Posted by: David from Canada, May 04, 2008 04:58:46 AM
This piece is a grand slam. To know Beyer is to despise him--a complete megalomaniac. As usual, he’s a complete transparent phony and full of more waste than all the barns at Churchill. Then again, he’s just a typical sportswriter with paper-thin skin. What else is new?
Posted by: horseman 2600, May 03, 2008 07:11:26 AM
|
Post a comment
Feel free to leave a comment or ask a question. Because of the prevalence of spam, we ask that you fill out the code in the image below to help us eliminate spam comments. By posting here, you affirm that you are 13 years of age or older. Washingtonian.com reserves the right to remove or edit content once posted.
|
|
|
