Not only is she arguably the most controversial woman, but she might be the most written about as well. An unusual addition to the glut of Clinton-related books, Speaking of Hillary is a collection of mostly previously published pieces on—and in a few cases, by—Hillary Clinton, from her childhood to her husband’s 1992 election to her own Senate candidacy.

This style of biography allows us not only to revisit the subject in “real time” but also to see our own prior perceptions through the lens of what we know now. Did we really once wring our hands over how Hillary would fulfill her duties as First Lady? How quaint!

Contributors range from columnists Maureen Dowd, A.M. Rosenthal, and the late Meg Greenfield to playwright Wendy Wasserstein and intellectual gadflies Camille Paglia and Christopher Hitchens. If there’s an op-ed dryness to some of the writing, it’s balanced by occasional brilliance. In one case, this unintentionally distracts: Henry Louis Gates’s absorbing 1996 New Yorker profile, “Hating Hillary,” is so well done that the whole time I couldn’t help thinking, as least as much as I thought about Hillary, just how damn good New Yorker profiles are.

Speaking of Hillary—try to overlook the college-syllabus subtitle—is a reminder that history is being written, and rewritten, every time we pick up a newspaper or magazine.