Book Review: “Nostalgia” by Dennis McFarland

Publisher: Pantheon

Price: $15.57

Book Review: “Nostalgia” by Dennis McFarland

The title of Dennis McFarland’s dreamlike, often harrowing Civil War novel, Nostalgia, refers not to a benign longing but to a serious—and, among soldiers in that conflict, much diagnosed—condition akin to posttraumatic stress. Summerfield Hayes, a Union private incapacitated by a blast and suffering from “nostalgia,” has been abandoned in the chaos of battle while advancing through Virginia. 

His goal is to get to Washington, “not be killed as a deserter on the way,” and from there return home to Brooklyn. He does make it to “Washington City” via a hospital where, struck mute, he’s surrounded by degrees of pain and pathos, including an amputee who cradles his stump as if it’s a baby, that test his compassion. 

Into this way station steps a visitor, poet Walt Whitman, and it’s through Hayes’s relationship with the gently transgressive writer that McFarland plumbs the novel’s deeper mysteries. “Maybe it’s not so bad, losing the so-called art of speech,” Whitman muses. “Most of life gives language the slip anyway, I find. Look at me: I rattle all day long and into the night and say only a fraction of what I feel . . . .”

McFarland, a master of words himself (“. . . over the surface of the pool, the moon has knit a quivering net of silver-white ropes”), tells a story in which the clamor of war competes with “the brilliant impenetrable silence, the speechlessness, the loss of meaning.” Within that tension it is Hayes’s—indeed, anyone’s—task to find an imperfect peace.

This article appears in the October 2013 issue of The Washingtonian.