Journalists Join Suit Against Administration: Bamford Calls NSA “Rogue Agency”
By
Harry Jaffe
Why would James Bamford, the preeminent journalist covering the National Security Agency, join a lawsuit against the government for expanding NSA’s secret surveillance of Americans?
Reason: “The ACLU asked me,” he says. But there’s more to it than that. Last week the American Civil Liberties Union sued the Bush administration for violating Fourth Amendment guarantees against unreasonable searches and seizures based on the government’s acknowledgment that it had ordered the NSA to eavesdrop on US citizens without first obtaining warrants required by law. Bamford, who writes books and recently published a groundbreaking article in Rolling Stone about the US propaganda machine, joined writers Christopher Hitchens and Tara McKelvey as plaintiffs. “The NSA is doing something very wrong in my opinion,” Bamford tells The Washingtonian. “It’s my obligation to speak out and make the case. There has never been a time when the law has been so blatantly violated by the White House.” Bamford spoke Friday before a House Judiciary Committee hearing called by Democrats and chaired by Detroit’s John Conyers, the committee’s ranking Democrat. With a friendly panel before a friendly audience, Bamford explained how the NSA works and argued that its expanded domestic surveillance violates the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. Bamford says he has special standing. “When the NSA was attacked by Europeans for helping American companies, I defended it before the European Parliament,” he says. “I never saw a single indication that NSA eavesdropped on Airbus and passed it along to Boeing. “Since I stood up for NSA and defended their actions, I’m not being inconsistent in going against the NSA when they’re being charged—fairly—with breaking the law.” Bamford wrote Puzzle Palace, the first definitive book on the NSA, in 1982. He followed that with Body of Secrets and in 2004 published A Pretext For War, about the Bush administration’s run-up to the war in Iraq. He says the NSA has become “a rogue agency.” Did he have qualms, as a journalist, joining a lawsuit against the government? “I don’t write for a newspaper,” he says. “I write books, and I put my opinion in my books.” The chances that the ACLU lawsuit will get past the first stages seem slim. “The threshold is that you have to show how you were impaired by government action,” says Jamin Raskin, professor of constitutional law at American University. “The problem with suing the government with regard to NSA spying is that no one knows if they have been spied upon.” Says Bamford: “Nobody has standing in that nobody has proof they were wiretapped. My writing has been impaired because it’s more difficult to get sources when the government can listen to anyone.” Ann Beeson, ACLU’s lead counsel on the case, says she recruited Bamford, Hitchens, and McKelvey as plaintiffs rather than newspapers such as the Washington Post. “We wanted to show how ordinary Americans and their jobs are affected by illegal wiretapping,” she says. “We purposely chose freelance reporters. Also, it’s a more onerous process to get publications to sign on. We wanted individuals, not companies.” Beeson says the government has 60 days to respond. Says Bamford: “You never know where a lawsuit will go.”
|
|
Honoring local heroes whose good works and generous spirits make Washington a great place to live and work
more
A suicide bomber in Afghanistan killed seven of the CIA’s own, including one of its best terrorist trackers. New details about Jennifer Matthews—and her secretive life—provide an inside look at a bloody and unfinished war.
more
Tevi Troy shares his tale of a career first.
more
A look back on AIDS through the years, from its first report in 1981 to the creation of DC's commission to combat AIDS in 2011
more
The national "open carry" movement, in which gun owners openly—and legally—carry guns in public, began in Virginia a decade ago. Meet three women who aren't bashful about it.
more
Sold for $1, the venerable weekly is about to become one of Tina Brown's media spectacles.
more
For 39 years, The Washingtonian has honored those who bring help and hope to the neediest among us, give at-risk children a fighting chance, enrich our educational and cultural lives, and make Washington a better place for all of us.
more
Prosecutors in DC have the toughest caseload in the country. But working here is also the best training ground for young lawyers—if they can handle the pressure. These are their stories.
more
Woo at the Zoo, the opening of “Genesis Robot” at Synetic Theater, and the Washington DC International Wine & Food Festival.
more
Our recommendations for the best in live music over the next seven days.
more
|