100 Best Restaurants 2009: Pete's New Haven Style Apizza

Reviewed by Todd Kliman , Ann Limpert , Cynthia Hacinli , Rina Rapuano , Eve Zibart

No. 83: Pete's New Haven Style Apizza

Pete's New Haven Style Apizza

1400 Irving St., NW
Washington, DC 20009
Phone: 202-332-7383

Cuisines:
Pizza, Italian, American

Opening Hours:

Wheelchair Accessible:
Yes

Nearby Metro Stops:
Columbia Heights

Price Range:
Inexpensive

Dress:
Informal

Noise Level:
Chatty

Reservations:
Not Accepted

Special Features:
Kid Friendly

Website:
Click here to open in new window.

Best Dishes
Antipasto plate; crispy goat cheese salad; Pete's Original pizza (with tomato and mozzarella); New Haven pie (with chopped clams); Sorbillo's Original; pasta with braised short ribs.


 

Reader's Rating:
3.8 out of 5

Cuisine: Few pizzas are as refreshingly unpretentious—or as large—as the 18-inch versions at this Columbia Heights eatery. The New Haven–inspired, thin-crust pies also can be had by the slice.

Mood: Floor-to-ceiling windows bring the urban bustle into the dining room, but the space is softened by butter-hued walls and wooden furniture.

Best for: Grabbing a slice to go; a quick meal with friends before or after a show or movie.

Best dishes: Seasonally inspired antipasti, which have included a quinoa salad with beets and walnuts and grilled summer squash; white-clam pie; pizza topped with pepperoni or fennel-scented sausage; Sorbillo’s Original, a turnover filled with cured meat, ricotta, and mozzarella; gelato from Georgetown’s Dolcezza; amaretti cookies.

Insider tips: During weekday happy hour, 4 to 6:30, a pint of Peroni beer plus a slice of cheese pizza is $5. If you’re customizing a pie, stick to a couple of toppings—the pizzas can get too heavy when they’re loaded.

Service: ••

Open daily for lunch and dinner. Inexpensive.

>> See all 100 Best Restaurants 

Reader ReviewsWrite your own review
 
Average Expansion
jkgf — August 25, 2009 12:51 PM
I would love to try this pizza and would love it even more if they would expand their delivery area to include upper connecticut avenue (van ness area)...:-)
Report the content
 
Excellent New Haven pizza
joya12201 — August 10, 2009 6:51 PM
The best pizza I have ever had in washington DC.
Everything I had was perfect. My hats off to the Mehrs and the Marrs.
Joya
Report the content
 
Average $25 pizza = dirt cheap?
dcgdc — April 21, 2009 11:00 AM
I thought the pizza was good but wouldn't call a $25 pizza dirt cheap...
Report the content