Bride & Groom MOM Subscribe

Find Local

Best Bites Blog > Feedback

Chew on This: Is it Fair to Judge a Brand-New Restaurant?

In the first few weeks of a restaurant's life, there are inevitably hiccups—slow service, too much salt here, too little pepper there. Such was the case for one reader who participated in restaurant critic Todd Kliman's chat today, talking about an experience at the newly opened Michel by Michel Richard in Tysons Corner. "Shrimp dish was very poor," the reader wrote, "something you would get at Red Lobster… .We spent $245 for 2 people. I think Michel has a bomb here." Following Kliman's response (which included a "caution about writing the obituary of a place that just opened and, because of that—and because of the towering reputation of its chef—deserves the time to find itself."), readers went back and forth on visiting a restaurant in its infancy. We want to know what you think: Is it fair to pass judgment on a brand-new restaurant? Does your opinion change if a meal costs $245 for two people?

Let us know in the comments.

Subscribe to Washingtonian
Follow Washingtonian on Twitter

Follow the Best Bites Bloggers on Twitter at

More>> Best Bites Blog | Food & Dining | Restaurant Finder


Read Next

Hidden Eats: Taco Bar

blog comments powered by Disqus

Most Popular on Washingtonian

The Summer Drinking Semifinals: Denizens Brewing Co. vs. Jack Rose

10 Offbeat Date Ideas in Washington

An Abridged History of Places Being Labeled the "Brooklyn" of Washington

The Summer Drinking Finals: POV Lounge vs. Jack Rose

Donald Trump Sues José Andrés Over Old Post Office Hotel Restaurant

The 15-Step, Absolutely Perfect Burger

6 Great Swimming Holes Near Washington, DC

Things to Do in DC This Weekend July 30-August 2: BRNDA, a Midnight Run, and "Hip-Hop Meets the Music of Ireland"

21 Things to Do in DC This August