Newsletters

Get Well+Being delivered to your inbox every Monday Morning.

In Defense of Frank Gehry
The memorial commission responds to charges that the planned Eisenhower memorial resembles a “theme park” and says the family has made “factual errors.” By Carol Ross Joynt
Comments () | Published January 30, 2012
Daniel Feil: “The eight-foot-high wall behind the sculptural grouping provides the location for excerpts from three of Eisenhower’s most famous speeches. These elements form the memorial core.” Illustration courtesy of Gehry Partners.

Recently we ran a Q&A with Susan Eisenhower, granddaughter of former president Dwight D. Eisenhower, about her family’s uniform objections to the proposed Frank Gehry design for the Dwight D. Eisenhower National Presidential Memorial, which is to be built adjacent to the Mall and the Lyndon Baines Johnson Department of Education. Eisenhower compared the design to a “theme park” and said the family objected to it on many fronts, including whether it was environmentally sustainable. Also, she said, it “has its back” to the education department, and her grandfather “didn’t have his back to Lyndon Johnson.”

In response to that post, we heard from Daniel J. Feil, who has served as executive architect for the Eisenhower Memorial Commission for the past six years. He said the Susan Eisenhower interview had “an ill effect,” and that the Commission’s point of view should be heard, too. Here is our conversation:

What was the ill effect of the Q&A with Susan Eisenhower?

There are factual errors.

What do you consider to be the factual errors?

She says the original concept was a green square and that it was going to be open, like Farragut Square or other squares in town. It really wasn’t the case. It has become more and more green, and that has been a promise to the review agencies. The paving has been really minimized.

She also objected to the metal tapestries?

The idea with the tapestry is creating a setting for the memorial. The tapestries are not the memorial. They are the setting for the memorial.

What about the Eisenhower family’s concern that there will be a wall separating the memorial from the Department of Education?

Education had that concern initially. But we have worked with them. We erected mock-ups that were 10 by 15 feet, showing different ways we thought the tapestries might be effected. They saw one design they thought might be quite wonderful. The tapestries are 70 feet away from the building.

The Education Department has endorsed the Gehry design?

Yes. And we got a letter from Secretary Arne Duncan about wanting to develop the LBJ Promenade, which will connect the Memorial and the ED. That promenade gives a fabulous chance to engage with the public. The Department of Education is now working with the Gehry team.

Daniel Feil: “The core is located within the civic space, which is a park defined by the tapestries. The tapestries are the setting for the memorial.” Illustration courtesy of Gehry Partners.

Do you think the family should have a say?

They have had a say. David Eisenhower was a commissioner.

But he quit.

Yes. But he was involved in the selection of Gehry, and he voted for the Gehry design. On March 31, 2009, he was part of the unanimous vote for Gehry and his team. On March 25, 2010, he voted along with all the other commissioners for the scheme that has the tapestry and the core within, which celebrates [Dwight Eisenhower’s] achievements as a president and as a general. There are images in the core of him addressing the 101st Airborne one day before D-Day, and the other is by Yousuf Karsh of him just after his presidency, with his hand on the globe, which speaks to his presidency and his internationalism. They will be on a heroic scale. David Eisenhower voted for the concept, and on July 12, 2011, he voted in favor of the development of the design and seconded the motion.

When did he resign?

Toward the end of December.

There’s also been controversy about the reported selection of Charles Ray to do a sculpture of Eisenhower as a boy.

He’ll be in his teens.

Will he be naked or clothed?

Clothed. But the sculptor has not been engaged.

So you’re still looking for a sculptor?

Yes. We hope to have someone engaged in the next few months.

Are you the principal liaison with Gehry?

Yes.

He was thwarted in his proposed design for an addition to the Corcoran Gallery in 2005 due to budget issues. Does he get tired of trying to design things for Washington?

Not that I’ve heard. The Corcoran was disappointing for them, but that was different. His office understands that every city has people and organizations you have to work with. This process is the process it is. You always have groups you need to work with.

What’s the next stage?

We’re going to the National Capital Planning Commission March 1 for preliminary design approval. We are also trying to engage with the family before that, with Susan and Anne in particular, and we are moving forward.

Do you expect significant public blowback at the NCPC hearing?

I would expect there will be a fair amount of public comment.

Do you think any additional changes will be made to the memorial?

There will be changes, because we are going through review processes, and we want to continue to engage the family. But the changes at this point should not be large. We went to the Commission on Fine Arts for approval, and it was unanimous and enthusiastic.

When do you hope to break ground?

By the end of this year.

Do you think there are too many memorials in Washington?

It’s not for me to say.

What do you want to say to the Eisenhower family?

I’ll tell you what I said to them. I said there was a lot of focus on the tapestries initially because they had not been done before. Tapestry is a traditional memorial form. We had to have a research and development phase to prove it could work, to prove it could be sufficiently transparent. There was quite the parallel effort on the core. I would ask them to once again try to engage and see the core for what it is. They will see that the tapestries are not as dominant as previously thought.

Categories:

Heard Local News
Subscribe to Washingtonian

Discuss this story

Feel free to leave a comment or ask a question. The Washingtonian reserves the right to remove or edit content once posted.
  • lll0825

    LYP-Nike as a historic brand is popular in all over the world,nike australia occupies a very important position. No matter what age the person will have a pair of Nike Shoes. This shows that people love the Nike.nike shoes australia's success depends largely on accurate market positioning and excellent quality. A lot of people are eager to buy cheap nike shoes, stores often only discount after last season's, how to buy a pair of cheap Nike? Now you can come to nike shoes online store. You can buy an ultra-low price of one pair of the latest nike free,nike sb.Or the girls favorite nike heels!Whether you own a pair of nike shoes to the face of such temptation, you should be in this hot summer,let your feet enjoy it.

    Order products in christian louboutin sale store are free shipping.If you want to be more remarkable,do not miss it christian louboutin high boots. They are sexy and gorgeous christian louboutin pumps. Welcome old and new customers christian louboutin sandals, we will offer you the best service christian louboutin slingback.All shoes has been worked by good craftsman and christian louboutin bags for men by hand and this is the result of a careful selection. If you are engaged in the vogue or you want keep the same pace with the trend, christian louboutin evening could be your best choice.It is really nice of you to share the excellent shoes information to others. christian louboutin shoes is absolutely representative of fashion and recreation, christian louboutin 2012, became a matter of course the popular protagonist of the season christian louboutin ankle boots. We will try our best to satisfy you christian louboutin wedges.

    I appreciate for your kind and generous sharing. Shop online at christian louboutin sale mall for a great selection of christian louboutin 2012, wedding shoes, evening christian louboutin ankle boots, boots and sandals for girls, women and men with free shopping on all orders.Welcome to luxury christian louboutin high boots online store.The best christian louboutin bags at best price, free delivery, easy returns & exchanges, 100% quality guarantee! Save 82% Off. Cheap christian louboutin evening makes a woman's feet dazzle and shine even after the twelve strikes of midnight. Own a pair of stylish and wonderful christian louboutin flats is women's lifetime pursuit. We offer christian louboutin pumps red bottom shoes online shopping by an elegant but easy way. Shopping online at discount price for red sole signature designer christian louboutin sandals, from christian louboutin sandals, christian louboutin pumps, christian louboutin wedges,christian louboutin slingback and christian louboutin boots.

    A lot of women like herve leger.This herve leger high neck dresses blue will make you very sexy and charming.Once you wear this beautiful,elegant, sexy and charming featured herve leger dress in the party,herve leger square neck dresses Black make your choice to go in the fashion front,herve leger strapless dresses the pursuit of fashion on the interpretation of the fashion herve leger swimsuit .Herve leger long sleeve dresses green make your choice to go in the fashion front, the pursuit of fashion on the interpretation of the fashion, sexy, charisma, temperament and so on.has always been favored in recent years,herve leger round neck dresses Green is enjoy a great reputation in the whole world,herve leger single strap dresses refined and elegant style of popular fashionable tide of people’s affection.herve leger bandage dresses is the famous brand from France. herve leger double shoulder is committed to shape the women’s line beauty, and the dress is known as the bandage dress.

    Once you wear this beautiful, elegant, sexy herve leger sale shop, you will immediately love it. Buy now cheap herve leger shop enjoy take one week to your door. They have become the most loyal fans in herve leger dress sale. Herve leger is equal to the charm of the Hollywood stars. Buy now herve leger dress free shipping. You herve leger dress clothing close friends as human beings, especially women, is necessary and important to the modern women shop herve leger dress.It is really nice of you to share the excellent shoes information to others.herve leger bandage dresses with beautiful clothes,herve leger dresses have the best durability, is to use artificial silk, nylon,herve leger dress shop spandex clothing popular with the people around the world of harmony. Ladies, show the perfect body for clothes.

    christian louboutin sale is french hot brand in the world,We provide different kinds of christian louboutin usa. Choose the woman wearing louboutin slingback, often has realised that many men somehow to high-heeled shoes have deep interest, wear cheap christian louboutin sneakers can easily outright conquest many men, can easily get many men worship,can easily make many men excited.In fashionable arena occupies a place of christian louboutin ankle boot forever and always makes women fascination.christian louboutin pumps foot that one wipe enthusiastic red, no matter how plain clothes, they were unable to hide the hostess as fire the lively personality.christian louboutin sandals is fashionable and beautiful, recently new appearance of new women's sandals, presenting an one colour profusion, design and material collocation also ingenuity, pretty, both restoring ancient ways, full of female lasting appeal, sweet call a person fondle admiringly.christian louboutin 2012 is fashionable and beautiful, recently new appearance of new women's sandals, presenting an one colour profusion, design and material collocation also ingenuity, pretty, both restoring ancient ways, full of female lasting appeal, sweet call a person fondle admiringly.Delicate the luxury of girl for oneself of each clothes to acquire a pair of high heels to match, but always than a double take christian louboutin ankle boots to reality.A pair of shoes match different dress, you can mature, can also be lovely, shoes with a woman share experience, no matter you are in the life which stage, whether a portly figure or thin, christian louboutin sales store always with you.But this kind of pretty woman flavour, just a kind of thin with the christian louboutin high boots predraft high-heeled shoes peculiar patents.

    The summer came again, if you have love to choose a pair of christian louboutin shoes right now? christian louboutin pumps daffodile match herve leger bandage will make you a shine at the moment.Don't do the most brilliant and also don't do the lowest. christian louboutin sandals with its own language, confided women the curve of the gentle, sending out the mature female charm. herve leger dress replica a fair maiden temperament, both costly and qing li, both charm and cute. Thank you for giving the awesome suggestions for us to order. summer comes, want to follow the trend of the front line, still please read the article. christian louboutin sale and clothes, the fire and herve leger dress is popular all over the world. Women like the bandage as the sexy details, they use replica herve leger bundle out of sexy figure concave and convex have send.

    nike high heels as a classic in nike numerous series is popular in the majority of female friends.In 2012 summer,Nike released a slew of new,including nike heels,jordan heels get consumers alike.nike high heels australia store have hundreds of styles,every nike dunk high heels are carefully selected.The feedback has been supporting our new and old customers,all our goods are at the lowest discount sales.And you do not have to worry about that we have any quality problems.Because all of our nike high heels shoes are made ​​to order directly from the factory,no tax,so our prices are far lower than the stores.If you are a passion for the Nike Madam,Please come to our store to buy it.

    NIKE name, in the eyes of Westerners was very lucky, easy to read and easy to remember,it is known.nike shoes trademark symbol of the Greek goddess of victory wings of feathers,representing the speed, but also represents a dynamic and gentle.nike australia's trademark,the pattern is a small hook shape concise,rapid as lightning,and a look reminiscent of the speed and explosiveness of nike shoes australia.For the first time named "Nike" athletic shoes, soles square convex tablets to enhance the stability, the body of the shoe on both sides of the knife-shaped curved hook,a symbol of the wings of the goddess.God's wings.nike shoes online store for Australian consumers,sell cheap nike shoes.Our aim is to let people around the world dressed in Nike. Whether you want to nike shox,nike dunk,or nike free,you can certainly find in our mall. We will provide you with the best online service!


blog comments powered by Disqus

Posted at 03:39 PM/ET, 01/30/2012 RSS | Print | Permalink | Comments () | Washingtonian.com Blogs