Where to Buy Thanksgiving Pies and Desserts Around DC

Complement your turkey with pies, cookies, doughnuts, cupcakes, and more.

1789's Thanksgiving dessert offerings. Photograph courtesy of 1789 Restaurant.

No Thanksgiving table is complete without a mountain of sweets at the end, and DC restaurants and bakeries have everything you’ll to need to satisfy your guests’ dessert cravings.

Brookland’s Finest
3126 12th St., NE
Chef and co-owner Shannan Troncoso is bringing back her crowd-pleasing chocolate chip pecan pie this year. The pie serves six to eight people and is topped with a spiked bourbon caramel drizzle. Pre-order it online for $35 by November 19 for pick-up on November 23. 

1226 36th St., NW
In addition to its dine-in pre-fixe menu, 1789 also has pies to-go. Find a spiced pumpkin cheesecake with caramelized pecan and chantilly cream, a pecan pie, or a cranberry sweet potato pie with caramelized walnuts and apple cider chantilly cream. Place your order by November 20 for pick-up on November 23. 

Call Your Mother
Multiple locations
Liven up your Thanksgiving dessert with CYM’s chocolate alfajor pie with dark chocolate ganache and dulce de leche, candied walnut pumpkin pie, or apple-cranberry cobbler. All three are available for pre-ordering for $35 until November 20, with pick-up on November 23. 

Bayou Bakery 
1515 N. Courthouse Road, Arlington
Try something new with chef David Guas’ bacon and cayenne pecan pie or Virginia peanut pie, or play it safe with the traditional pumpkin, classic pecan, lemon chess, or roasted sweet potato. Prices range from $22 to $26. Pies must be ordered by November 19 for pick-up by November 23. 

Chocolate chip pecan pie from Brookland’s Finest. Photograph courtesy of Scott Suchman

District Donuts
749 8th St., SE; 5 Market Square, SW; 1309 5th St., NE; 4238 Wilson Blvd., Arlington
Go bold with doughnuts for dessert this Thanksgiving with District Donuts’ fall menu. Choose from flavors like maple butter pecan, pumpkin glazed, and apple cider. The fall flavors stick around all November long; order online for Thanksgiving day. 

Bread Furst 
4434 Connecticut Ave., NW
Stick with the classics: apple, pumpkin, and bourbon pecan pie for $32.50 each. Act quick – once they run out, they’re out. Call 20-765-1200 to order

Neighborhood Provisions
2000 Mt Vernon Ave., Alexandria
If you don’t want to tempt yourself with a whole pie, you can have to option of just half of a pumpkin, dutch apple, or pecan pie. Of course, we can’t blame you if you opt for the entire thing. The full pie is $36 and half is $18. Order online for pick-up or delivery on November 22 and 23. 

Pie Shop
1339 H St., NE
For those who can’t decide which flavor they want this year, Pie Shop has you covered. They have a Berger cookie pie, traditional apple, apple crumble, sweet potato, chocolate pecan, chocolate peanut butter chess, blueberry pancake, pumpkin, and a winterberry crumble. Their pre-orders are all sold out, but they have pies available for walk-ins every day on a first-come first-served basis. All pies are $36. 

The Cakeroom
2006 18th St., NW
Try their Banoffee pie, a traditional English dessert made from bananas, whipped cream, and graham cracker crust, or another from their wide selection. They have key lime, peanut butter chocolate, sour cream walnut apple, and three berry pie in addition to their fall-flavored cupcakes. All pies are $28 and cupcakes are $38 to $44 for a dozen. Order 48 hours before pick-up. 

Firehook Bakery 
1909 Q. St., NW; 430 South Washington St., Alexandria; 14701 Flint Lee Rd., Chantilly
Decorate your table with festively shaped and iced cookies or pumpkin bars. Firehook also has the classics like apple, pecan, and pumpkin pie if you can’t live without. Pies are $22-$24 and cookies and bars are $10-$14. Order 48 hours before pick-up. 

RavenHook Bakehouse
1309 5th St., NE
Try their Texas pecan pie ($35) or their mile-high apple pie. ($32). Order by November 20 for pick-up by November 23. 

Mr. Bake Sweet’s
Delivery only
Take your pick of pies, cakes and even a banana pudding from Mr. Bake Sweet’s. He is offering sweet potato, pumpkin, bourbon pecan, and apple crumb pies, or sweet potato, red velvet, and southern chocolate cakes. Pies are $30-40, cakes are $65, and the banana pudding is $50.

Dolcezza Gelato
Multiple locations
For the month of November, the gelato maker rolled out flavors like spice cake batter, maple syrup and cinnamon walnut pesto, mascarpone and fig, and sweet potato pecan praline. They are available to pick up at any of their locations. 

Editorial Fellow

Keely recently graduated with her master’s in journalism from American University and has reported on local DC, national politics, and business. She has previously written for The Capitol Forum.