We, the Pizza is finally proclaiming “We are open.” Top Chef: Chicago contestant Spike Mendelsohn’s new pizzeria—next to his Capitol Hill burger joint, Good Stuff Eatery—is turning out New York-style pies, classic subs, Italian sodas made with fresh fruit, and homemade gelato. Mendelsohn and chef Mike Colletti say We, The Pizza is their answer to the dominance of knife-and-fork Neapolitan pies in Washington. “You can’t go anywhere and pick up one slice of cheese pizza unless it’s Jumbo Slice at four in the morning,” Colletti says.
Between a truffle-laced wild-mushroom pie and Colletti’s grandmother’s meatballs, the duo can’t quite narrow down their favorite menu items. But they have a pretty good idea what the Top Chef judges would like: “Padma would order pizza with sausage and peppers,” Mendelsohn says. “Tom would probably do the porchetta sandwich [with slow-roasted pork and fennel/mustard-seed slaw], and he’d probably try a slice of cheese just to see how our dough is.” Check out the rest of the menu here, and see the new digs in our video tour.
Subscribe to Washingtonian
Follow Washingtonian on Twitter