Get Where+When delivered to your inbox every Monday and Thursday.

Is the FBI Director Short List Really Just One Name Long?
Comments () | Published April 1, 2013

The Washington Post is short-listing the possible candidates to replace Robert Mueller as FBI Director, after he ends his tenure this summer. At the top of the list, says the paper, is Lisa Monaco, who recently ran the National Security Division at the Justice Department, was Mueller’s longest-serving chief of staff, and is now at the White House in CIA Director John Brennan’s old job. 

Lisa Monaco, who is currently President Obama’s counterterrorism adviser, may be the leading candidate for FBI Director. Photo: Justice Department 

The list could probably stop at Monaco, given how improbable the other people on it are. Putting aside Monaco’s legitimate credentials, and the fact that her name has indeed been making the rounds over the past few months—I’ve heard it from the lips of FBI watchers and former Justice Department officials—the other people on this list are not likely to want the job or be able to easily sail through confirmation. 

Let’s take them one at a time. 

Merrick Garland is an esteemed jurist, chief of the U.S. Appeals Court for the D.C. Circuit, and widely seen as a potential nominee for the Supreme Court. Why on earth would he give that up to be the FBI Director? Garland has also been out of the game, on the executive branch side, for a long time. He took his seat on the bench in 1997. The Justice Department he worked in during the Oklahoma City bombing and the Unabomber investigation was a very different place than it is now. He is also, perhaps, too closely associated in the eyes of many experts with the he culture of the department pre-9/11, when intelligence and law enforcement operations were separated by statute, mistrust, and misunderstanding. 

James Comey, who was deputy attorney general to John Ashcroft, is, by my read, greatly enjoying his life in the private sector and the benefits that go with it. He has recently worked for defense contractor Lockheed Martin, the high-profile hedge fund Bridgewater, and recently took a seat on the board of directors of HSBC Holdings. Comey cares deeply about national security and counterterrorism issues, but he can exert  a lot of influence in those areas from his private perch, which brings him into proximity with decision makers in business and in government. Also, I think that Republicans would see him as too liberal, and Democrats would see him as too conservative. (A testament to his intellectual honesty, perhaps, but not likely to make him a shoe in for Senate confirmation.) And PS—Did you catch the part about him working for a defense contractor and a hedge fund? Optics problems abound here, fairly or not. 

Patrick Fitzgerald’s name gets trotted out whenever there’s a vacancy in a senior Justice post. I think people toss it onto every short list just to make it look longer. His political baggage as the prosecutor of Scooter Libby is enough to kill his chances.  

Neil MacBride, maybe in five years or so. He needs more seasoning. If he’s truly on a short list, and not just thrown in artificially, he’s a longshot. 

For good measure, or maybe for levity, the Post also quotes the national executive director of the Fraternal Order of Police, Jim Pasco, who suggests the White House consider Philadelphia Police Commissioner Charles Ramsey, who used to be the D.C. Police Chief and who has never held a federal position, or Ray Kelly, the New York Police Commissioner. Who is 71 years old. 

It’s worth noting that Garland, Comey, and Fitzgerald also surfaced on a short list reported in the Wall Street Journal in 2011, along with Ken Wainstein, Michael Mason, John Pistole, and Jamie Gorelick, whose names aren’t surfacing now. (Although, I know some non-partisan experts who think highly of Wainstein and have mentioned he’d be a good candidate.) 

And missing from the Post’s article are some names that seem more plausible than the ones reported. For instance, how about David Kris? I doubt he’s interested in returning to Washington from his corporate counsel job in Seattle, but he’s got more obvious credentials in the operational aspects of law enforcement and intelligence than many of the candidates on the current list. For that matter, why not Fran Townsend? Granted, she’s a Republican, and probably quite content in private practice and working as an on-air analyst for CNN. But if we’re talking about plausible candidates here, you have to look to people who have done substantial work of the kind that will consume much of the FBI Director’s attention. 

Monaco really fits that bill more than anyone on the list, in terms of her recent experience and its depth. Also, nominating her would allow President Obama to make history; a woman has never led the FBI. As I noted last week, after Obama picked Julia Pearson to run the Secret Service, the tide has obviously turned in favor of more women in top security positions. Even if Monaco doesn’t get the nod for the FBI, a woman eventually will, and not, I think, in the distant future.  


FBI White House
Subscribe to Washingtonian

Discuss this story

Feel free to leave a comment or ask a question. The Washingtonian reserves the right to remove or edit content once posted.
  • occupy los ├íngeles

    You left off Dr C. Rice of the Bush Administration . A case could be made for an T.RO prohibiting an appointment of an all white male the tradition for the last 100 years or so. See the history of the appointments to the FBI Chief position in last 75 years or so.
    This is especially true the government unlawfully extended the current FBI chief mandatory 10 years out of office term due to expired 8-3-2011 for an unheard additional two years in expectation that Dr. Mueller fellow brother in the Mormon faith Mitt Ronmey would have appointed him two another 10 year term once he was elected to be the 45th President . This would have been his reward for clandestinely helping in plotting to have his friend President Obama assassinated unexpectingly by the mormon Miafia . See the Federal Case in the Central District of California 12 cv 00297 where a motion is pending via the administrative procedure act to declare said extension unconstitutional and have a woman replace Dr. Mueller for years of discrimination.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Posted at 11:16 AM/ET, 04/01/2013 RSS | Print | Permalink | Comments () | Blogs