IM’ing Top Chef Masters

Elizabeth WILL cut you. Photograph courtesy of Bravo

Last night, the second installment of Top Chef Masters pitted four more celebrity chefs against each other: Wiley Dufresne, the mutton-chopped molecular gastronomer behind New York's WD-50; Elizabeth Falkner, the Susan Powter-haired owner of San Francisco's Citizen Cake; Graham Elliott Bowles, a tattooed Chicago chef that calls his cooking style "punk rock"; and Suzanne Tracht, a Los Angeles chef who looks like she's spent some time in Lindsay Lohan's tanning bed. In other words, plenty of fodder for our IM conversation during the show. 

Alejandro: Ready for round two?
Kate: Ready!
Alejandro: Episode two better bring it.
Alejandro: Kelly Choi, I am ready for you.
Kate: Kelly Choi, I’m ready for you to show me why you’re hosting this show.
Alejandro: And why you make speaking look so hard. It’s like enunciating alone takes too much out of her.
Alejandro: Oh, look, I actually recognize someone this time—it’s Wylie!
Alejandro: He better do some molecular voodoo.
Kate: Punk rock for Graham Elliott Bowles. I like it.
Alejandro: Love his emo glasses.
Alejandro: Suzanne Tracht’s restaurant is called Jar? LAME.
Kate: Whoa fake tanning.
Kate: And she sounds like a robot.
Alejandro: Suzanne, honey, say it with me: skin cancer.
Kate: Has she ever heard of emotion?
Alejandro: Speaking of emotion: I am swooning over Wylie.
Kate: You dig the hair? Or the chops?
Alejandro: They’re no Hubert locks, let’s put it that way—but as long as he delivers.
Alejandro: Eek. Scary-lady alert for Elizabeth.
Kate: Edible Schoolyard—that’s a cop out.
Alejandro: Look at Suzanne—she’s already asleep.
Kate: Oh hello, useless Kelly. A roll of quarters? 
Alejandro: She’s as thin as the roll.
Alejandro: Vending machine challenge? Ugh.
Kate: Better than Girl Scouts.
Alejandro: Someone better pick Cheez-its. I love Cheez-its.
Kate: Oh man. I. Love. Cheez. Its.
Alejandro: AGHH! Scary blonde lady with blonde tips again. Careful or she WILL hit you.
Alejandro: Why are people being nice to each other?! It’s a competition. BE MEAN!
Kate: That’s the problem with the whole charity aspect of this.
Kate: I think Graham’s going to give Wylie a run for his money.
Alejandro: Yeah, I’m team Wylie, but he’s panicking.
Kate: Oh no. Your man choked.
Alejandro: Elizabeth’s name is too long to type. I’m gonna start calling her Liz.
Alejandro: It’s better than scary blond lady, right?
Kate: If I had to make something out of the vending machine, it’d include Cheetos, a Take Five bar, and those disgusting/amazing peanut-butter cracker things.
Alejandro: I was just about to ask.
Alejandro: I’d use Cheez-its, Pepsi, Skittles, and Sour Skittles—because one kind of Skittles is never enough.
Alejandro: Speaking of vending machines—what’s with the shameless Dr. Pepper plugs?
Kate: They plugged it on the last Top Chef, too.
Alejandro: This is worse than the plugs on 30 Rock or even One Tree Hill.
Kate: I really think Suzanne’s dish tastes bad just based on the fact that she’s not excited.
Alejandro: Could be the Botox’s fault. You never know.
Kate: Beef jerky and ice cream?
Alejandro: Uh-oh for Liz.
Kate: Damn, look at Graham.
Alejandro: He should win by virtue of not using Dr. Pepper.
Alejandro: We should start playing what from now on will be dubbed the Kelly Eating Game. It’s like The OC drinking game’s rule about Marissa.
Alejandro:  Every time we see Kelly actually eat, we have to chug a beverage.
Kate: Haha OK.
Kate: My money’s on Graham.
Alejandro: Wylie’s a sore loser.
Alejandro: What! Boring tan face won?
Kate: That’s crap.
Alejandro: Boring winner, boring show.
Kate: I think Wylie just said he wants to take you to a tiki bar.
Alejandro: Come again?
Kate: Ew, Kelly even tries to have Padma’s mannerisms.
Alejandro: Look! Suzanne emoted!
Kate: Haha. Elimination Challenge time.
Kate: Oh Wylie, I’ve never seen Lost either.
Alejandro: Lost supper?
Kate: “The Lost Supper”?
Alejandro: How….clever.
Alejandro: I love me some Lost, but this is a weak challenge. Worse than those Project Runway contestants making clothes “inspired” by cars.
Kate: Yeah, I don’t even get this challenge.
Alejandro: Like Lost!
Kate: Come again?
Alejandro: No one gets that show either.
Alejandro: Epiphany number two! Maybe that’s what they’re going for with the episode?
Kate: Excitement?!
Alejandro: Utter confusion.
Alejandro: Again with the helping each other. It really needs to stop.
Kate: They’re feeding each other!
Kate: I’d love to see a cat fight between Lizard and Tan Lady.
Alejandro: Sous-vide-ing something is always a risky move. Liz should know better.
Alejandro: Just ask Carla. 🙁
Kate: I feel like if there’s one thing I’ve learned from watching these shows: If they say “I saw so-and-so running around,” it’s a bad sign. And Wylie’s training for a marathon or something.
Alejandro: Yeah. he looks, well, lost.
Alejandro: Thank you, I’ll be here all night.
Kate: WHOA floral Kelly.
Alejandro: Jeez, that flower is bigger than Kelly’s head.
Kate: Wylie’s running…again.
Alejandro: Wylie, get it together! The servers are dressed as Dharma Initiative people. That’s cute.
Kate: Weird.
Alejandro: Or weird, if you’re not familiar with the show, I suppose. Here come the Lost writers.
Alejandro: No, Damon Lindelof, the real challenge is for you to tell me if Juliet will live again.
Kate: That papaya pudding didn’t look too appealing.
Alejandro: That Asian woman was bitchy. Loves it. She should take over Kelly’s job.
Alejandro: Graham is good. He’s won me over.
Kate: Graham is so the winner.
Kate: Even his glasses are better than Wylie’s.
Alejandro: Oh crap. I can’t believe Wylie did such a poor job plating.
Alejandro: It was bad. Season-two-of-Lost bad.
Kate: Wylie, that joke’s not gonna get you out of the fire.
Alejandro: Again with the Lost writers. You don’t understand the dish, says you? I don’t understand your show!
Kate: Wow, that’s a lot on a plate: uni, boar, oyster, beer.
Alejandro: Look at Graham being so humble.
Alejandro: He pounded them.
Kate: Put your money down now: Who’s gonna win? I want Graham, but I think Tan Lady has it.
Alejandro: Graham deserves to win, but Crazy Tan Lady might take it.
Alejandro:  Why can’t Top Chef be a bit more like Real Housewives of NJ? I mean, I’m not saying we should have the Top Chef masters asking each other about their buh-bbies and turning over tables, but some drama would be nice.
Alejandro: So we agree Graham should take it, but not ruling out Suzanne?
Kate: No, Suzie Q may very well take it.
Alejandro: If she takes it, I think we should see her victory as an omen of things to come.
Kate:  Only the most tan will win?
Alejandro:  That or the most boring will claim victory.
Kate: Oh Lizzy, no one’s laughing with you.
Alejandro: Told ya. Sous vide is the quickest way to lose.
Kate: Tan Lady’s a judge favorite. It’s between her and Graham.
Alejandro: Did he just call Wylie’s food sci-fi food?
Alejandro: It’s molecular gastronomy, not time-traveling.
Kate: OK, why don’t they just tell Tan Lady she won?
Alejandro: You know what this episode is missing?
Kate: Fun?
Alejandro: Tom Colicchio.
Kate: Kelly has made me appreciate Padma so much more.
Alejandro: People think looking pretty is easy, but no one does vacant eyes like Padma.
Kate: OK, this is ridiculous. They can’t be such good friends—it’s too feel-good.
Alejandro: Look, they’re eating cookies together. Why don’t they paint each other’s toenails while they’re at it?
Alejandro: I don’t think this show will be back after this season.
Alejandro: Nice equals death on reality TV. Unless you’re that loud scary dude helping build new homes for people.
Alejandro: We need an asshole Top Chef master.
Kate: I just want this to be over. This show is not worth my lost sleep.
Kate: Tan Lady’s got it in the bag, anyway.
Kate: Bye-bye, Wylie.
Alejandro: One down.
Kate: Oh Liz, go eat your cookies.
Alejandro: Back to the kitchen, and hopefully the hair salon.
Kate: Did they just call Tan Lady seductive?
Alejandro: She just won.
Kate: And didn’t even smile!
Alejandro: If I were stranded on an island with a working television I would not want this show playin’ on it.
Kate: God, no. I’d throw the TV out.

Last Week's Top Chef Masters IM Conversation

More>> Best Bites Blog | Food & Dining | Restaurant Finder

Don’t Miss Another New Restaurant—Get Our Food Newsletter

The latest in Washington’s food and drink scene.

Or, see all of our newsletters. By signing up, you agree to our terms.