Food

Columbia Firehouse (Full Review)

In Old Town, Columbia Firehouse fits right in

Michael Babin, co-owner of the Neighborhood Restaurant Group, has a knack for creating restaurants that fit perfectly into their surroundings. They range from the popular Birch & Barley/ChurchKey on DC’s 14th Street to the quietly ambitious Vermilion in Old Town. In the same Alexandria neighborhood is Columbia Firehouse, which opened a year ago but had a rocky start. Its original idea—half steakhouse, half bistro—didn’t jell, and the opening chef left after a month.

But the restaurant drew customers into its rustic dining room, a soaring space with exposed brick that hints at the building’s 19th-century roots as a firehouse. The bar area, popular with a younger crowd, feels more like a dark and clubby saloon.

Dishes in the dining room are a cross between pub fare (burgers, chili) and trend-conscious American bistro food (meatloaf, three kinds of steamed mussels). Some creations—such as hand-cut French fries with pimiento-cheese, goat-cheese, and smoked-mayo dipping sauces and the crunchy fried chicken with buttery cornbread—marry the two concepts well. Others, such as a Reuben sandwich reinvented as egg rolls, miss the mark.

Many dishes are typical of casual neighborhood restaurants: good-enough food that sometimes surprises. In this category are baked oysters, decadent with bacon and cheese, and a hanger steak with béarnaise sauce. Desserts are at the top of this class. A take on a chocolate Hostess cake puts most cupcakes in town to shame, and a fudgy square of brownie is nearly as good.

Columbia Firehouse has a pleasing quality that works well with Old Town’s crowd of families, tourists, bargoers, and foodies. In other words, it fits right into the neighborhood.

-August 2010 

Don’t Miss Another New Restaurant—Get Our Food Newsletter

The latest in Washington’s food and drink scene.

Or, see all of our newsletters. By signing up, you agree to our terms.
SIGN UP
We engage readers directly in their mailboxes with topics like Health, Things to Do, Best Brunches, Design & Shopping, and Real Estate. Get the latest from our editors today.
Get The Best Of Washingtonian In Your Inbox!