First Look: Medium Rare

A different kind of steakhouse opens in Cleveland Park: there's one set menu—and it comes with second helpings.

The steak-frites, left, comes with a great gravy over the top; the outside of the restaurant. Photographs by Scott Suchman

Slideshow: Steak—and More Steak  

In the restaurant world, what’s old is new again: suspender-clad bartenders, comfort-food classics. That’s one reason the two-month-old Medium Rare in DC’s Cleveland Park has been an instant hit. The inspiration behind it is a Parisian restaurant that opened in 1959, Le Relais de Venice L’Entrecôte, where the menu couldn’t be simpler: It offers one fixed-price dinner—salad and steak frites—plus a handful of wines, and there are no reservations. Then, free of charge, you can get a second portion of steak and fries.

See Also:

Outtakes: Reviewing Farrah Olivia

Outtakes: Reviewing Hill Country

Owners Tom Gregg and Mark Bucher, founder of BGR the Burger Joint, have made some American tweaks: Their $19.50-a-person menu includes a vegetarian option (a grilled portobello mushroom with roasted-red-pepper sauce), diners can get ketchup for their fries, and Pearl Jam and Led Zeppelin play on the speakers. The low-ceilinged, 70-seat space—formerly the Greek restaurant Yanni’s—is also streamlined, with exposed brick and butcher-paper-topped tables.

A L’Entrecôte idea Bucher stuck with: The makeup of the sauce on the steak frites remains a secret. Whatever it is—we taste cream, mustard, and black peppercorns—it’s good. The meat, a dry-aged sirloin-cap steak, and the McDonald’s-like fries can be great, though there has been some inconsistency: Second portions of steak can be overcooked, and fries were crispy one time, soggy another.

Among the desserts—think big slices of Carnegie Deli cheesecake and six-layer carrot cake—the hot-fudge sundae is the winner, just the way you remember it, down to the rainbow sprinkles. How’s that for a throwback?

Medium Rare, 3500 Connecticut Ave., NW; 202-237-1432. Open Monday through Friday for dinner, Saturday and Sunday for brunch and dinner. Set meal $19.50, dessert $8.

This article appears in the June 2011 issue of The Washingtonian.

Subscribe to Washingtonian
Follow Washingtonian on Twitter

Follow the Best Bites Bloggers on Twitter

More>> Best Bites Blog | Food & Dining | Restaurant Finder

Don’t Miss Another New Restaurant—Get Our Food Newsletter

The latest in Washington’s food and drink scene.

Or, see all of our newsletters. By signing up, you agree to our terms.