Allison and Erin Blakely greet customers from behind the counter. Photograph by Jeff Martin
Dine-in guests order slices and mini pies with a side of chocolate, vanilla, or strawberry ice cream. Photograph by Jeff Martin
“Cuppies” include a savory chicken pot pie, perfect for lunch or an afternoon snack. Photograph by Jeff Martin
The sisters top their Key lime pies with a healthy dollop of cream. Photograph by Jeff Martin
A coconut cream pie gets a dusting of toasted coconut and a smattering of stars. Photograph by Jeff Martin