50 Top Journalists 2009

As the media landscape changes and once-powerful papers wither, who are today’s top reporters? Here’s our quadrennial review of the city’s best and most influential journalists.

By Garrett M. Graff    Published Monday, June 01, 2009

A new generation of journalists rising to the top includes CBS’s Lara Logan, ABC’s Jan Crawford Greenburg, the Atlantic’s Joshua Green, Hotline’s Amy Walter, the Washington Post’s Chris Cillizza, and the New York Times’ Charlie Savage. Photograph by Matthew Worden.

Every four years since 1973, The Washingtonian has picked the city’s 50 best and most influential journalists. The original list—heavy with regional-newspaper bureau chiefs and light on television reporters—bears little resemblance to the present-day world. Since 2005 alone, the media landscape has changed dramatically.

The creative destruction brought about by the rise of the Web has accelerated: Even in major cities such as Boston, daily newspapers are hanging by a thread. Hundreds if not thousands of Washington reporters have lost their jobs as local papers have pulled back on their DC coverage. The Washington Post has 300 fewer newsroom staffers than it did in 2005.

The last four years have seen a growing disconnect between daily beat reporters and a smaller class of “impact” reporters, whose bylines may appear less frequently but who move governments, policies, and news cycles when they do write. Politico.com has built one of the few successful new journalism models around being the first with every small tidbit of news—even if its reporters don’t always get it right at first—and is causing the Post leadership some indigestion in doing so. Using a business model that values links from Drudge and cable-news hits more than Pulitzers, Politico relies on its writers to blog constantly and eschews in-depth reporting. It aims for—and hits—the inside-the-Beltway gossip crowd who can never get enough.

On the other hand, Michael Isikoff of Newsweek and Jane Mayer and Ryan Lizza of the New Yorker change the way readers see the world—even if the public sees their bylines only a handful of times a year. While beat reporting remains the heart of journalism, news-of-the-day scoops are increasingly irrelevant. Politico notwithstanding, the advent of an Internet-driven news cycle has made it matter less who beat whom to what story by ten minutes.

Looking for lasting impact? Check out journalism pieces such as the Post’s exposé about Walter Reed Army Medical Center by Dana Priest and Anne Hull, Mark Leibovich’s eviscerating New York Times Magazine profile of Chris Matthews, and virtually anything by Bob Woodward in the Post. Perhaps counterintuitively, long-form writing seems to matter more today than ever. Tom Friedman’s books have done more to shape the way business thinks about globalization—and more recently, “green” technology—than just about anything said by any corporate leader. They’ve established him as arguably Washington’s most powerful journalist.

This list, complied based on interviews with dozens of the Washington journalism establishment, is biased toward reporters who will shape our views of the Obama era. Sadly gone from the roster are a host of once-powerful correspondents for chains such as Knight Ridder and the Tribune Company, whose empires are melting away before our eyes. Underscoring that fall from grace, not a single reporter from a Tribune paper has made this list in 2009.

The list marks another milestone: Since 1973, only two reporters have made every iteration of it—David Broder and Bob Novak. That streak that comes to an end in 2009, as both men have effectively retired from day-to-day journalism. The baton is being passed to a different generation, one raised on blogs and schooled in Twitter, for whom the idea of an am-and-pm news cycle is as far removed from their reality as the telegraph.

This list includes only journalists who live in the Washington area, thereby excluding some very talented and influential writers such as Talking Points Memo’s Josh Marshall and Politico’s Ben Smith, both based in New York; People’s bureau chief, Sandra Sobieraj Westfall, a New Jersey resident whose portraits of Washington power players are read by millions; and the Post’s dwindling pool of foreign correspondents.

In alphabetical order, here are our picks for the best and most influential Washington reporters in 2009.

Mike Allen, Politico. The seemingly inexhaustible Allen writes all day, beginning with his early-morning must-read, Playbook, which is to the Obama administration what ABC’s The Note was to Washingtonians five years ago.

Marc Ambinder, Atlanti c. Thoughtful, well sourced, and unimpeachably fair, Ambinder, in his blog and magazine pieces, is the antithesis of the often-vapid cable-news talkfest.

Peter Baker, New York Times Magazine. Although he’s a Russia expert, Baker—who jumped from the Washington Post after his wife, Susan Glasser, was pushed from that paper—is a strong utility player, writing smartly on a range of topics.

Dan Balz, Washington Post. Still going, just like the Energizer Bunny, Balz continues to crisscross the country and churn out quick analysis that puts to shame many others who have more time.

Carl Cameron, Fox. Whatever you think of his network, players on both sides of the aisle trust “Campaign Carl” and know that his reporting is second to none.

Chris Cillizza, Washington Post. A blogger, vlogger, Twitterer, and reporter, Cillizza is the model of what the next generation of Washington reporter will look like.

Richard E. Cohen, National Journal. The unofficial dean of congressional correspondents—not to be confused with Washington Post columnist Richard Cohen—offers an unparalleled depth of analysis and context to his coverage.

Helene Cooper, New York Times. After covering the State Department, Cooper finds herself newly prominent with a post covering the White House and a best-selling memoir, The House at Sugar Beach: In Search of a Lost African Childhood.

Candy Crowley, CNN. Few people in TV journalism are as respected, balanced, or hard-working as “Candy,” who seems to know most campaign developments before the campaigns do.

Jeanne Cummings, Politico. In a city of lobbyists and lawyers, Cummings, a Wall Street Journal veteran, is perhaps Washington’s best expert on the business of making policy.

Comments


TO THE WASHINGTONIAN,MY LETTER IS FOR YOUR HELP CONCERNING MY GOVERNMENT TRAGEDY,WHICH INVLOVES [DISCRIMINATION&CORRUPTION]FROM THE ILLINOIS VETERANS AFFAIRS IN LAKE COUNTY,IL.60064,NANCY GALLAGHER/RUBY TURNER,THE ILLINOIS CHURCHS&WASHINGTON,DC.20420,VA.OFFICERS,MS.LAVINE,[202]565-5436,[1995-2009]EACH ORGANIZATION INVOLVED IN SUCH GOVERNMENTS OF[FRAUD,SABOTAGE,ENTRAPMENT]AS PART OF MY LIFE IN CHICAGO,IL.60610,U.S.CITIZEN,U.S.NAVY VET.345-60-8985,[9/2/58],CAUSING [COMMUNISM,CAPITAL PUNISHMENT,&APARTHEID],TO STRONGLY EXIST WITHIN MY WELFARE,CITIZENSHIP,&SOCIAL ACTIVITIES IN CHICAGO,THESE ARE HELPFUL REFERENCES,JAMES PARKER,JESSE MORALES,HILDA MUNIZ,SALLY MORRISSON,JILL VORNHORFF,BRUCE COTTON,MIKE VAUGHN,PAT HOOVER MORGAN,JEREMY SMITH,RICK EDDY,JAMES FRAZIER,TANYA HAWKINS,BLAIR STEVENSON....PLEASE SEND ME YOUR HELP FOR MY GOVERNMENT TRAGEDY,THANK YOU,R.MORGAN

Posted by: RUDEL MORGAN, Sep 15, 2009 04:20:38 PM

I would have liked to see this list broken down into categories. Seems to me you have a preponderance of PUNDITS. I don’t know all of them, but I bet there’s a preponderance of conservative-leaning pundits. No Krugman, No Ezra Klein? That seems to be Washington, though. So, maybe you’re right on. We have the Internet for the opposing view.

Posted by: Watered down-Washington, Aug 31, 2009 05:50:19 PM

What about the editors?

Posted by: Alexandra, Jun 15, 2009 05:09:21 AM

What about Amanda Ripley?? Where was she?

Posted by: Eye Roller, Jun 11, 2009 07:59:46 PM

This is a bad list -- of course many of these are good journos but clearly not written from someone in the trenches. Not one person from AP? Regional newspaper reporters? The authors of this list just plucked the most obvious names and tallied up the most appearances on the cable networks. I’d be interested in who real DC journos (those who cover the White House, Congress etc., not just those on the party scene) think are the best reporters. There would probably be some names you haven’t heard of. I guess these people are doing good PR for themselves though!

Posted by: bad, Jun 11, 2009 08:10:15 AM

Only one person from Fox and no one from The Washington Times, CBN or the Weekly Standard? Do I detect a bit of bias here??

Posted by: Julia Duin, Jun 11, 2009 07:22:19 AM

Susan Page

Posted by: Carolyn Blaydes, Jun 10, 2009 11:36:57 AM

I’m sad to see that you don’t list Elizabeth Wynn Johnson of Capitol News Connection. Her writing is fresh, witty and at times sarcastic - what a treat - and is always a propos.

Posted by: Doreen Christian, Jun 08, 2009 02:07:53 PM

Feist deserves a journalism award for bringing a breath of fresh air to the presidential debates. The marriage of the old (TV) with the new (YouTube) worked, and there’s nothing wrong with a little flash & sizzle if one gets results. If the critics would take a look at the record of the YouTube debates, for the first time in decades they would see politicians, when face to face with a real live voter, feel obliged to actually try to answer the questions. By the end of these debates, the candidates had divulged more about themselves than we have witnessed in a long, long time. Certainly more than we usually see in the typical debate hosted by "journalists" during which the candidates play "run out the clock" question after question.

Posted by: knowathingor2, Jun 08, 2009 07:11:49 AM

This is a high concept gag column, right? You took some real playing cards -- Coll, Lithwick, Cook, Taylor -- and mixed them in with some of those gag playing cards that feature playboy bunnies as queens and credulous buffoons as knaves ... ? Shuffled the deck for kicks, right? I get it, I think.

Posted by: eyeball, Jun 05, 2009 10:37:53 PM

Brilliant satire! Hiatt as journalist? Ooofff! Stenographers and apologists for the powerful like Simon and Taylor and Will? Blogger-worthy snark. Although, one little quibble: the addition of a (very) few actual journalists to the list, as opposed to rest of the D.C. cocktail weenie set, dilutes the quality of your effort ever so slightly.
If you’re going over the top, as the aforementioned members clearly indicate, cull the actual journos.

Posted by: Strangely Enough, Jun 04, 2009 02:50:56 PM

Link bait+beat sweetener. Oh, and you’ve still got something on your chin.

Here’s more on <a href="http://24ahead.com/s/anne-kornblut">Anne Kornblut</a>.

Feist was involved with the CNNYoutube debates; it’s too bad he could be sued by America over how bad a public service he and the rest of those involved did.

<a href="http://24ahead.com/s/politico">The Politico</a> is a joke.

Posted by: 24AheadDotCom, Jun 04, 2009 02:48:30 PM

Post a comment

Feel free to leave a comment or ask a question. Because of the prevalence of spam, we ask that you fill out the code in the image below to help us eliminate spam comments. By posting here, you affirm that you are 13 years of age or older. Washingtonian.com reserves the right to remove or edit content once posted.

Find A ...
Find A Restaurant







  1. Only show Delivery
    Only show Kid Friendly
    Only show Late Night
    Only show Party Space
    Only show Weekend Brunch
Find Events




Find A Happy Hour





  1. search_finda.gif
Find A Spa




  1. search_finda.gif
Find a Home





  1. search_finda.gif
  2. Powered by  
Find A Hotel


  1.   


  2. Reviewed by Washingtonian
  3. Kid Friendly     Valet Parking
    Handicap Accessible    

  4. Childcare
    WiFi
    Pet Friendly
    Bar/Lounge/Dining
    Airport Shuttle
    Salon/Spa
    Swimming Pool
    Fitness Room
    On-site Drycleaning
    Meeting Rooms
    Golf
    Tennis Courts
    Game Room
  5. search_finda.gif

Make Mine a Single: Valentine’s Parties Where You Don’t Need a Date

Who needs a stinkin’ significant other anyway? Here’s a list of parties where all the single ladies (and gentlemen) can party this Valentine’s Day weekend—and where you might even find your next soulmate. more