There’s something really satisfying about finding your Holy Grail of beauty products, yes? And though there’s no question that our hearts hold a lot of love for luxe-level brands like Kevyn Aucoin and Chanel, when that MVP find comes straight from the shelves of your corner CVS . . . well, it’s doubly awesome. Click through the gallery to get a glimpse of the drugstore finds we keep going back to—and that completely belie their wallet-friendly price tags.